A Dispole Antenna by Rick Littlefield, K1BQT ...
|
Note: I have always found antenna design interesting and this design is no exception.
Rick's description of this antenna is extremely clear.
I found this information interesting and have saved it since I cut it out of RF Design in May 1997.
I have not contacted Rick LittleField regarding my recreation of it (I had it in paper form) and putting it on
my web site so I hope it is okay with him. I have recreated it as accurately as possible and provided him with the
credit as well as included his amateur radio call letters and his own comments from www.qrz.com.
Should he not desire it to be here I will certainly remove it • Larry P Thomas, wa0gwa.
|
Wireless data links and other emerging forms of low-power communication have created a market for compact
indoor and outdoor antennas in the 150 MHz to 1 GHz range. Concern over RF exposure from cellphones and
hand=held transcievers has kindled an aggressive search for safer UHF radiators. The discpole antenna
design may provide for both of these applications.
The discpole is a capacitively loaded, off-center-feed (OCF) dipole proportioned such that a 50 Ω
feedpoint occurrs at the junction of the element and one loading disc. (see Figure 2) Functionally,
the discpole provides the following electrical and mechanical characteristics.
Figure 1
Figure 2
Antenna is vertically polarized.
A feedpoint is provided athe the antenna base.
The vertical elem,ent is 50% shorter than a halfwave dipole (0.24 λ).
The radial footprint is 15% that of a quarterwave resonant counterpoise (0.036 λ).
Current loop is symmetrical, with I-max occurring at the element mid-point.
The element is fully isolated, thus preventing common-mode feedline radiation.
No external matching network is required for 50 Ω operation.
On-horizon performance is equal to that of a halfwave dipole.
Discpole evolution
The discpole is compared and contrasted with other designs in Figure 3. When conventional, center-fed,
halfwave dipole (A) is reconfigured as an end-fed vertical, it typically takes the form of either a sleeve
antenna (B) or a ground plane using bent radials in resonant counterpoise (C). In an alternate form, the
ground plane may be implemented as a 50 Ω OCF dipole by lengthening the upper element to approximately
0.32 λ and shortening the radials (D). To modify the OCF dipole for capacitive loading, a disc may
substitute for the radial wires to form a single-disc loaded vertical (E). The true discpole is formed by
installing a second disc at the top of the radiator (F). Installing a second disc of equal proportions reduces
disc diameter and shortens radiator length, and at the same time redistributes RF current to the center of the element.
Figure 3
Efficiency
Despite its small physical size, the discpole is an efficient RF radiator. At least two factors contribute to
this efficiency. First, although monopole-like in appearence, the discpole functions as a balanced dipole radiator
with an evenly distributed current loop forming at mid-element. (See Figure 4) This prevents pattern tilting and
afforts maximum radiation efficiency on the horizon. Second, although the discpole has a lower mid-point
impedance than a dipole, there are no lumped constants or mechanical breaks in series with the radiator to
increase the percentage of Ωic loss. As a result, high efficiency is maintained.
Figure 4
VSWR and bandwidth
A properly constructed discpole normally exhibits a voltage standing wave ratio (VSWR) of 1:1 at its intended
frequency of resonance. At 150 MHz, the discpole's 1.5:1 VSWR banswidth was measured at 7.5%, yielding a
useful operating span of approximately 10 MHz. Normally, one would expect a 50% reduction in element length
to constrict bandwidth severly. But, the narrowing effect of shortening the element is countered by broad-banding
effects of decreasing system Q.
Frequency scaling
Although the discone's overall size determines resonant frequency, the ratio of disc size to radiator length
sets the feedpoint impedance. Small discs paired with long element will yield a higher feedpoint impedance,
and a large disc paired with a short element will yield a lower impedance. The formulas below were developed
for scaling 50 Ω designs and should provide accurate sizing approximations as high as 500 MHz. Minor adjustments
may be required for variations in tubing diameter and mechanical structure:
Disc diameter in inches = (730+0.7•FMHZ) ÷ FMHZ
Element height in inches = 2800 ÷ FMHZ
Multiple resonances occur with the discpole, but these do not fall in a direct harmonic relationship with the
antenna's fundamental frequency. Harmonic detuning is a likely result of disproportionate capacitive loading
and inappropriete disc positioning at overtone frequencies.
Feed system
When the discpole is proportioned for a 50 Ω feed, no external matching is required. However, because the
antenna is fed with unbalanced line at a point approximately 45 degrees off center, a coaxial choke must be
installed at the feedpoint. This prevents unwanted detuning and reduces common-mode currents from propagating
down the line and radiating. A minimum of 900 Ωs reactance normally is provided to ensure adequate isolation.
The required inductance may be calculated using the formula:
LµH = 900 ÷ (2•PI•FMHZ)
For low-power operation as high as 250 MHz, a choke may be wound from 0.1" Teflon cable (RG-316) and secured to
a 3/8" OD PVC form. From 250-500 MHz, an air-wound choke made from mini-hardline, such as RG-402 or semirigid
Beldon 1671A will prove more satisfactory. At frequencies higer than 600 MHz, the effectiveness of air-wound
chokes diminishes rapidly, and other more appropriete UHF decoupling techniques are recommended. To provide
adequate element isolation when mounting, the firat 1/10 λ of antenna's support mast should consist of an
RF insulating material such as hollow fibergalss stock of microwave tested PVC pipe.
Conclusion
To date, discpoles have been constructed sucessfully and tested at operating frequencies from 50 to 900 MHz.
Over this frequency range, field tests suggest that the discpole offers a compact and effiecient alternative
to traditional low-gain base-station designs. For example, range trials at 150 MHz have shown the the discpole
may be substituted for a halfwave dipole, sleeve dipole, voltage-fed halfwave stick, J-pole, ground plane or
radial decoupled OCF without measurable penalty. The discpole also promises to provide significant advantages
in hand-held applications in the 800-950 MHz band and above, where symetrical current distribution on a elevated
radiator is advantageous and where chassis-borne radiation may constitute a medical liability for manufacturers.
References
1. Provisional U.S. patent protection for the discpole antenna has been applied for.
2. Rick Littlefield, "The two Meter Discpole Antenna," Communications Quarterly, Summer 1996.
About the Author
| Rick Littlefield is an independent RF-Design engineer specializing in two-way voice and
data communication equipment. Currently cintracting with MFJ Enterproses, Starkville, MS, he is also a columnist
for Communications Quarterly and a frequent contributopr to several other technical publications.
|
This is the information about Rick Littlefied, K1BQT, currently on WWW.QRZ.COM which was last modified 2005-02-12.
|
I go by Rick and was first licensed in Maine at 13 back in 1957 (not much else to do up theyah back then).
Graduate of Mass Radio in Boston and UNH Durham (BA,MEd). Currently work as a Product Engineer and designer
for Cushcraft in Manchester NH after 10 years designing for MFJ and some tech writing for Ten-Tec. Been
experimenting, building, and writing since the early 70's with over 100 articles published. Member of the
ARCI QRP Hall of Fame. You can sometimes find me on Ham Radio's "dark underbelly" (3936) in the evening
running QRO and talking trash with old friends. My wife, Terry, is former editor of Ham Radio Magazine
and founding Editor of Communications Quarterly Magazine (now merged with QEX). Step-son Drew, N1XIM, is a
Computer Engineer at the University of Maine and son Robin is majoring in M.E. at the University of NH
where he seems to prefer cars and girls over ham radios. Thank god one member of the family turned out
normal!
|
|
|